Court Records


July 13, 1984

United States District Court
Eastern District of North Carolina

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings

Appendix
Tab A: Affidavit of Jimmie Proctor
Tab B: June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), with attachments:
  • Attachment #1:
    Jan. 26, 1971: CID Case Progress File

  • Attachment #2:
    April 28, 1971: Letter from Col. Tufts to U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge, with CID 1st Progress and Substantiation

  • Attachment #3:
    April 13 - May 25, 1971: CID 2nd Progress Report

  • Attachment #4:
    April 13 - May 25, 1971: CID Investigation Report excerpt

  • Attachment #5:
    Sept. 8, 1972: Letter from U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge to Alfred Hantman (DOJ). declining prosecution of Jeffrey MacDonald

  • Attachment #6:
    Sept. 26, 1972: Routing Slip
Tab C: July 12, 1984: Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh

July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 1 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 1 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 2 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 2 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 3 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 3 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 4 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 4 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 5 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 5 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 6 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 6 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 7 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 7 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 8 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 8 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 9 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 9 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 10 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 10 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 11 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 11 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 12 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 12 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 13 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 13 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 14 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 14 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 15 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 15 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 16 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 16 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 17 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 17 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 18 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 18 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 19 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 19 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 20 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 20 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 21 of 19
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree from Participation in Post-Trial Proceedings, p. 21 of 19


Tab A
Circa July 12, 1984:
Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor
[Last page(s) missing from copy received]

July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 1
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 1
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 2
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 2
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 3
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 3
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 4
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

Affidavit of Jimmie C. Proctor, p. 4


Tab B
June 30, 1984:
Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), with attachments

July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 1
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 1
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 2
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 2
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 3
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 3
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 4
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

June 30, 1984: Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID), p. 4



Attachment #1 to Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)
January 26, 1971:
CID Case Progress File

Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>January 26, 1971: CID Case Progress File
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

January 26, 1971: CID Case Progress File



Attachment #2 to Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)
April 28, 1971:
Letter from Col. Henry Tufts to U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge, with CID 1st Progress and Substantiation

Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>April 28, 1971: Letter from Col. Henry Tufts to U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

April 28, 1971: Letter from Col. Henry Tufts to U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>April 13, 1971: CID 1st Progress, p. 1 of 2
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

April 13, 1971: CID 1st Progress, p. 1 of 2
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>April 13, 1971: CID 1st Progress, p. 2 of 2
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

April 13, 1971: CID 1st Progress, p. 2 of 2
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>Substantiation
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

Substantiation



Attachment #3 to Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)
April 13, 1971 - May 25, 1971:
CID 2nd Progress Report

Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>April 13 - May 25, 1971: CID 2nd Progress Report, p. 1 of 2
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

April 13 - May 25, 1971: CID 2nd Progress Report, p. 1 of 2
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>April 13 - May 25, 1971: CID 2nd Progress Report, p. 2 of 2
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

April 13 - May 25, 1971: CID 2nd Progress Report, p. 2 of 2



Attachment #4 to Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)
April 13, 1971 - May 25, 1971:
CID Investigation Report excerpt

Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 1 of 4
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 1 of 4
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 2 of 4
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 2 of 4
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 3 of 4
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 3 of 4
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 4 of 4
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

CID Investigation Report excerpt, p. 4 of 4



Attachment #5 to Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)
September 8, 1972:
Letter from U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge to Alfred Hantman (Criminal Division, U.S. Dept. of Justice). declining prosecution of Jeffrey MacDonald

Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>September 8, 1972: Letter from U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge to Alfred Hantman (Criminal Division, U.S. Dept. of Justice), declining prosecution of Jeffrey MacDonald
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

September 8, 1972: Letter from U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge to Alfred Hantman (Criminal Division, U.S. Dept. of Justice), declining prosecution of Jeffrey MacDonald



Attachment #6 to Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)
September 26, 1972:
Routing Slip Which Accompanied September 8, 1972 Letter from U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge to Alfred Hantman (Criminal Division, U.S. Dept. of Justice)

Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)<br><br>September 26, 1972: Routing Slip Which Accompanied September 8, 1972: Letter from U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge to Alfred Hantman (Criminal Division, U.S. Dept. of Justice)
Attachment to June 30, 1984 Affidavit #3 of Peter Kearns (CID)

September 26, 1972: Routing Slip Which Accompanied September 8, 1972: Letter from U.S. Attorney Warren Coolidge to Alfred Hantman (Criminal Division, U.S. Dept. of Justice)


Tab C
July 12, 1984:
Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh

July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>July 12, 1984: Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh, p. 1
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

July 12, 1984: Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh, p. 1
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>July 12, 1984: Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh, p. 2
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

July 12, 1984: Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh, p. 2
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC<br><br>Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree<br><br>July 12, 1984: Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh, p. 3
July 13, 1984: United States District Court, EDNC

Attachment to Opposition to Motion by Jeffrey MacDonald Seeking Disqualification of Judge Dupree

July 12, 1984: Affidavit #4 of Brian Murtagh, p. 3